The article attempts to think through the original purpose of the Fifth Amendment and argues for an interpretation that emphasizes the notion of compulsion rather than the issue of self-incrimination.
The most important historical point that the authors make is that the Fifth Amendment was written in a period in which many countries used torture to elicit confessions. Even more importantly, much of European law was based on Roman Law, in which the testimony of slaves was considered invalid unless they were tortured. The authors thus suggest that we should read the word "compelled" as a key to understanding the purpose of the amendment. The point they make is that it was designed to prevent any form of compulsion. This is especially relevant in cases where confessions may, even now, be elicited by threats or other marginally unethical interrogation techniques, or even by police brutality.
The authors also argue that part of how we should think about the Fifth Amendment is in terms of the balance between actual evidence and testimony. They suggest that part of how we analyze the Fifth Amendment should emphasize that testimony is less reliable than other forms of evidence, such as physical evidence and paper trails.
Finally, the authors suggest that the Fifth Amendment should not be used to prevent defendants from testifying on their own behalf or providing testimony in general, but only that there should be no element of compulsion.
Thursday, October 5, 2017
What does the following article have to say about the Fifth Amendment and how it should be used in legal cases? http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1957&context=fss_papers
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Why is the fact that the Americans are helping the Russians important?
In the late author Tom Clancy’s first novel, The Hunt for Red October, the assistance rendered to the Russians by the United States is impor...
-
Lionel Wallace is the subject of most of "The Door in the Wall" by H.G. Wells. The narrator, Redmond, tells about Wallace's li...
-
In the late author Tom Clancy’s first novel, The Hunt for Red October, the assistance rendered to the Russians by the United States is impor...
-
The poem contrasts the nighttime, imaginative world of a child with his daytime, prosaic world. In the first stanza, the child, on going to ...
-
Friar Lawrence plays a significant role in Romeo and Juliet's fate and is responsible not only for secretly marrying the two lovers but ...
-
There are a plethora of rules that Jonas and the other citizens must follow. Again, page numbers will vary given the edition of the book tha...
-
Resourceful: Phileas Fogg doesn't let unexpected obstacles deter him. For example, when the railroad tracks all of a sudden end in India...
-
If by logos you mean argument by logic or the use of facts to prove a point, then there are plenty of examples in the book. Take, for instan...
No comments:
Post a Comment