Sunday, February 15, 2015

In "Two Kinds," what does the narrator's mother want her to become?

In "Two Kinds," the narrator's mother wants her to be a prodigy—meaning a young person who has an extraordinary talent that makes that child famous. At first, the mother thinks the narrator can become a kind of Shirley Temple, a child who sings and dances. When this doesn't work, the mother attempts to make the narrator into a kind of whiz kid who knows all the world's capitals or who can memorize a page of the Bible after looking at a page for three minutes. When this plan also fails, the narrator's mother dedicates herself to turning her daughter into a piano prodigy. This plan fails as well when the narrator seems to behave lazily and does not practice, and then the narrator embarks on a series of life choices that continue to frustrate her mother's desires for her.


Jing-mei's mother has recently emigrated to America from China, and she wants her Chinese American daughter to become a prodigy in some discipline. Together, they explore thoughts of Jing-mei becoming a singer and dancer like child star Shirley Temple or an academic whiz who can defeat all competitors on quiz shows. Finding no talent in those areas, Jing-mei's mother decides that playing piano will become Jing-mei's specialty. She purchases a piano and arranges lessons with an elderly Chinese man, and she pushes Jing-mei to practice, even when she resists. More than anything, she wants her daughter to be a public success who will win the approval or perhaps even envy of her fellow Chinese immigrants in their close-knit community. However, it is not to be, as Jing-mei possesses neither the natural talent nor the strong desire to be a prodigy.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Why is the fact that the Americans are helping the Russians important?

In the late author Tom Clancy’s first novel, The Hunt for Red October, the assistance rendered to the Russians by the United States is impor...